Liquid, pen and gel eyeliners are unique in their functionality and are actually formulated according to the user’s preference as well as the user’s expertise. Depending on the particular need of the intervention, the expected results and the level of ease while applying the different intervention types, people should choose the right type.
Here is an explanation of these commonly used eyeliner types so that you can determine which of the two is more suitable for you.
Introduction to Eyeliner
Eyeliner is one of the most important makeup products that gives the eyes, one of the most important features on the face, the shape and definition it needs. Whether it is to lengthen the eyes or give them a soft and comfortable look, the effect of eyeliner will be very powerful. Thick, thin, waterproof, subtle, bold – these all refer to the three types: liquid, pen and gel eyeliners that provide different feels and looks. This paper compares and contrasts the two and aims to provide an understanding of both and point out the advantages and disadvantages of each.
Liquid Eyeliner
Liquid eyeliners are popularly known for creating super fine eyeliner looks. They have water consistency which dries to a matte or glossy finish. With their epic pigment, they are ideal for creating dramatic looks.
Pros:
- Perfect precision: Better precise application becomes possible through the super fine tips which come as standard on liquid eyeliner products.
- Pigmentation: The pigment concentration in liquid eyeliners produces powerful coloring suitable for making bold looks.
- Long lasting: These eyeliners maintain their appearance for extended periods which outlasts alternative products found in the market.
Cons:
- Tough application: Beginners find difficulty in applying liquid eyeliners because of unsteady hands.
- Not good for waterline: Liquid eyeliners can cause irritation or itching if mistakenly it gets too close to the waterline.
Best Uses:
Liquid eyeliner is ideal for everyone those who want define the eyes area very clearly and with intension. This type of winged eyeliner is perfect for bold evening makeup, liner art, and those who like sharp wing or cat eye.
Pen Eyeliner
Pen eyeliners can be your prime choice if you have difficulty applying liquid liners or you are trying your hands on makeup. A pen liner is just like a sketch pen, beginner friendly and easy to use. They are best for on the go touch ups.
Pros:
- Smudge-proof: Pen eyeliner resists smudging because its fast-drying composition makes the product smudge-proof.
- Good for beginners: Liquid eyeliner suits novices because they apply easily due to their secure grip while offering smooth control.
Cons:
- Dries out quickly: Pen eyeliner tends to dry out fast, if not stored properly.
- Limited styles: Pen eyeliners are not versatile; one can’t make graphic styles with pen liner.
- Less pigmented: They are generally less pigmented than gel or liquid ones.
Best Uses:
Pen eyeliners are easy for daily wear, minor touch-ups and convenient for the beginners. It is especially suitable for natural makeup, regular makeup, or any time when you might need an eyeliner that you can rely on while traveling.
Gel Eyeliner
Makeup and Beauty influencers have popularized gel liners because of its flexibility. They usually come out in a small pot with a separate brush, good for a smoky eye look.
Pros:
- Ease of use:The creamy gel base provides smooth application leading to a mistake-free application of the liner.
- Waterproof and long lasting:Gel eyeliners stay waterproof longer than traditional eye liner formulas because they also provide extended durability.
- Diverse looks: Gel eyeliners allow users to generate either straightforward or attention-grabbing dramatic eye looks in addition to a variety of intermediate options.
Cons:
- Not suitable for beginners:Applying Gel liner requires proper technique, so it’s not suitable for people who are beginners.
- Dries out quickly: Gel eyeliners tend to dry out very quickly if not stored properly.
Best Uses:
Gel eyeliners should be preferred by those who like experimenting and making different smokey or blended looks. They are suitable for decorative makeup and for those people, who like to gradually deepen the intensity of the drawn line.
Liquid vs Pencil vs Gel Eyeliner: Comparing Key Features
| Features | Liquid Eyeliner | Gel Eyeliner | Pen Eyeliner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ease of application | Little tricky, not for beginners. | Easy after practice. | Perfect for beginners. |
| Pigmentation and Finish | Provides intense pigment. | Good pigmentation. | Less pigmented than liquid or gel. |
| Longevity and smudge resistance | Long lasting and smudge proof. | Long lasting, but it can smudge. | Long lasting and Smudge proof because of quick drying formulation. |
| Versatility & style range | Best for Bold, dramatic eye looks. | Best for smoky eyes effect. | Great for daily glam. |
| Suitability for Sensitive Eyes | No, if used near waterline. | It’s safe. | It’s safe. |
How To Apply Eyeliner?
- Shake the bottle before use and wipe out the excess liquid to avoid mess.
- Keep your hands steady and use smaller strokes.
- Start from the inner corner if you want a simple thin liner look and to get a winged or cat eye look start from the outer corner.
Expert Tips for Choosing and Applying Eyeliner
- Always keep your tools clean in order to protect your skin from infections.
- Do eyeliner styles according to your eye shape.
- To get a bold and dramatic liner look, try tightlining.
- To get attractive eye make-up. Always do Liner style according to your full-face makeup and outfit.
- Don’t forget to set your eyeliner with translucent powder or matching eyeshadow to get a clean look.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Don’t pull your skin while applying liner, this can cause wrinkles in the long term.
- Use shorter strokes instead of one long swipe.
- Try eyeliner styles according to your eye shape for a flattering look.
- Avoid over-smudging your liner.
- Never skip make-up primer if you don’t want flakey, cracked eyeliner strokes.
- Don’t leave the eyeliner bottle or pot open without closing its lid.
- Never remove eyeliner harshly, always use makeup remover to remove it smoothly.
Conclusion: Which Eyeliner is Best?
The type of eyeliner varies depending on the owner’s preference, skill, and the kind of look desired.
- Liquid Eyeliner is best suitable for those who want product that is precise with their looks.
- Pen Eyeliner is recommended for novices or for those, who don’t have time for a precise application.
- Gel Eyeliner is ideal especially for such trends and smoke and, especially if combined with blended inlay work.
In short, when it comes to applying and planning makeup, it is up to the individual to decide what they likes best. Try different types of makeup for a while and decide what works best for you and don’t hesitate to change different types of makeup according to your daily activities. Eyeliner, liquid, pen or gel maintains your makeup routine and your self-love.
Frequently Asked Questions About Eyeliner
Can I use eyeliner on the waterline?
Yes, the use of waterproof eyeliners is recommended when applying waterproof liner to avoid itching. The usage of liquid eyeliner is not recommended for this purpose.
What is the shelf life of eyeliner?
Gel and liquid eyeliner have a shelf-life span of 3 to 6 months but pen eyeliner extends to 6-12 months.
Why does my liquid eyeliner flake or crack?
The principal skin factor behind this timing is oiliness and dryness. Before creating your eye makeup choose a primer which both hydrates and operates without oils.
Can I smudge my liquid eyeliner?
No, using liquid liner for smudging will create an unprofessional appearance. Your best choice for achieving a smooth smoky eye effect would be gel eyeliner products.
Do I have to wet the brush before applying gel eyeliner?
Yes, the product becomes easier to apply through wetting it either with setting spray or water.
